One of my favorite movies not just of my school days but of all time. Released in 2004, A Cinderella Story took the classic fairy-tale and modernized as well as twisted it; to make the story more relatable to the people watching. Starring two of the hottest young stars at the time as our Cinderella and Prince Charming may have also played a part. Not sure why I should say it given everyone knows the Cinderella tale but just in case spoiler alert. I DO NOT OWN THE PICTURE.
Our Cinderella in this movie is Sam Montgomery (Hilary Duff). She loves baseball, her widowed dad’s diner and dreams of going to Princeton. Feeling Sam needs a mother figure her dad Hal (Whip Hubley) marries Fiona (Jennifer Coolidge) who seemed sweet when they met, but is clearly a self-absorbed gold digger. She brings along her twin daughters Brianna (Madeline Zima) and Gabriella (Andrea Avery) who are both dumb and selfish. Hal is killed during the 1994 Northridge earthquake and because he apparently did not make a will Fiona gets everything, including Sam to both of their dismays. Years later Sam is a servant in her own home and diner while her step family makes it look like they are living a good life (they happily water their lawns despite being told to conserve water during the drought). Because she works at the diner Sam is made fun of at her school by the popular kids, specifically head cheerleader Shelby (Julie Gonzalo). Sam it seems only has a few friends: her lifelong friend Carter (Dan Byrd) who is trying to be an actor and has an obvious crush on Shelby (he is blind to her mean ways), the people who work at the diner long before Fiona got there and her online pen pal Nomad she met in a Princeton chat room. They have a lot in common in their lives and dreams about Princeton, but they have never met. Unbeknownst to Sam, Nomad is actually Austin Ames (Chad Michael Murray) the high school quarterback, most popular guy in school and Shelby’s ex-boyfriend (which she has not come to terms with). He wants to go to Princeton but his dad that he wants Austin to go to the University of Southern California to play football.
Nomad wants to meet with Sam during the homecoming dance, but Sam is scared to (not to mention Fiona forced her to work the night of the dance). Rhonda (Regina King) Sam’s sassy other best friend at the diner and wanting to stick it to Fiona helps Sam get ready for the dance in a very Cinderella like dress and mask. Sam and Austin meet and to say Sam was thrown that the hottest guy in school is her pen pal would be an understatement. The two spend the evening talking and the two fall in love. However Sam is forced to leave before midnight in order to get back to the diner before Fiona gets there, but drops her phone as she and Carter (who in his Zorro costume finally managed to woo Shelby) escape. Austin finds her phone and the next day puts up fliers asking his Cinderella to come forward (which causes many girls to claim they are Cinderella including Brianna and Gabriella in hilarious fashion). Sam tries to tell Austin she is Cinderella, but is scared to because of how popular he is and how unpopular she is. About as far as I should go without giving away the rest of the movie, although I will say the last forty minutes are very satisfying.
Hilary Duff was my favorite actress when I was younger, and this to me was her best role. Watching Sam’s character development was amazing, especially the final parts of the movie when she comes in to her own. Chad Michael Murray was also a personal favorite of mine and again watching his character grow is fascinating. Jennifer Coolidge is wickedly good as Fiona, Dan Byrd is hilarious and Regina King is sassy and golden (one of my favorite characters in the entire franchise). Yes in case you didn’t know there are three more Cinderella story movies after this one staring popular teen stars, but those are for another day. I love this movie so much (although I would not call it must see) and if you like romantic high school comedies than this is the one for you.